2011年10月26日 星期三

放下 1 Detachment or Letting Go 1

Earlier, I was translating Master Ban Ji's book. She had a section on "Detachment." and I would like to expand on this topic. She had some issues with the common teaching that if one is able to let go of everything, one would immediately become Buddha. She questioned that if we let go of everything, will we still be able to live?


早些, 當我在翻譯半寄師父的書,
對師父寫關於「放下」的內容有些想法。
師父對「放下一切,立即成佛」的說法有點疑問。
她質疑:如果真的放下一切,我們仍然還活著嗎?


If we let go of all our worldly possessions, would we be running around naked looking for things to eat ?


我在想:如果我們放下所有的身外之物,是否需要赤裸裸的跑來跑去找東西吃呢?


If we let go of all our emotions and senses, wouldn't we become like stones on the field?


如果我們放下所有的情緒和感覺,不就變成跟石頭一樣?


Then I had a thought. Don't every one and every Buddhist books all expound on the idea that Bodhisattva is full of compassion? And that we need to be full of compassion. So that means Bodhisattva didn't have let go of compassion. Does that mean that we can keep out compassion too? Why don't we need to let go of compassion? If we get to keep compassion, what else do we get to keep?


那麼,我有一個想法。
大家跟所有的佛教書籍都說菩薩都充滿了慈悲心,
而且我們也需要跟菩薩一樣有慈悲心。
這不表示菩薩放不下慈悲這個情緒嗎?
為什麼我們不需要放下慈悲?不是要「放下一切」嗎?
如果我們能留慈悲,那還有什麼情緒可以保留?


Let us try to solve this issue by applying Śūnyatā to this issue.
Śūnyatā implies impermanence of one-self. To us, impermanence implies mutability, and mutability implies that we have a mean to control the change.


讓我們嘗試用對「空」的瞭解來解決這個問題。
「空」意味著「無我」跟「無常」。對我們來說,
「無我」跟「無常」代表易變性;
易變性表示,我們有控制變化的空間。

2 則留言:

匿名 提到...

想了一下,但不太懂最後一段
控制變化的空間~跟是否放下,放下什麼的關連,可否說得再詳細一些?

元, Yuan 提到...

Anonymous wrote:

I don't really under the last part. Does "a mean to control the change" a connection between letting go and what to let go? Can you please explain in more detail?

Hi! It will be explained in tomorrow's article. In this article, it is not about what to let go. I actually have another article that will appear later that will talk about what to let go.

嗨!這明天的文章會解釋。放下什麼不是這篇文章的重點。我已經寫了另一篇文章將會提到放下什麼。以後會出現。